fbpx

FREE Shipping!

For a limited time receive FREE Shipping on ALL orders!

SAVE 20%!

Save 20% on your first order with coupon code SAVE20

Vapor Lite 48"x100' (400ft²)

Our most economical Surface Protection product, Vapor Lite shares similar protective benefits from our White Vapor, but without as much latex or ‘hold’, so taping may be warranted.

$104.00

Buy In Bulk and Save!

Save on bulk orders of more than 14 rolls!

Do you know the truth about Sound Control Underlayment?

Property Managers, designers, and architects alike have to be knowledgeable about an extensive amount of issues to do with building systems and materials. Combine that with the challenging personalities one would have to deal with, and this industry can chew you up and spit you out whole. It’s especially difficult when you are dealing in an area where there is so much misinformation. The ‘Sound Control Underlayment market is one of those places where wild performance claims abound, yet solid testing information is rarely backing up the claims that the testing suggests. So, what is a person to do? Question everything! The purpose of this blog is to help people understand the sound control industry for flooring and to ask the right questions and gather the information required to make an educated decision about Sound Control Underlayment. It’s vital that any designer, architect, or property manager, not only protect their reputation but also demonstrate due diligence and potentially shield them from legal issues that may arise due to insufficient knowledge.

Sound Control Underlayment is being specified in condominiums and multifamily dwellings to keep the peace and allow the serenity of each resident’s suite. They must, when new, perform according to product claims; they also must not cause issues in the future. So where do you start? Well, it is imperative to ask the right questions:

  • How was the product tested? What building assembly was used? If it’s not clear in the literature, ask to see the test report.
    • Does it meet the IIC requirement of this building? What is a ‘reasonable’ requirement for the ‘financial demographic’ of your building?
    • What is the product made of? Really important for downstream problems. What will happen as this product ages? Will it harden, crush, dry out, absorb, or wick?

They seem like pretty simple questions, right? They are not! Many manufacturers of underlayment are betting on you not being an Acoustical Engineer and hope you will scan the sales literature for the highest Impact Insulation Class (IIC) rating, approve it, and get on with your day. Millions of square feet of sub-standard underlayment have been installed, leaving desperate residents, animosity towards neighbors, frustrated tenants, and management boards with ‘no win’ legal situations. Let’s look at each of those questions to understand what they truly mean.

1. What tests were performed?

The first red flag is product literature or packaging that shows an IIC rating but does not indicate the building assembly that it was tested on. This is by far the most common ruse. The producer of the literature is banking on keeping the PM or the general public in the dark about what IIC means. Higher is better right? This is where the field runs from truthful to deliberately misleading. If the indicated IIC ratings are in the high 60s or 70s and do not show the testing assembly – RUN! But what does IIC mean and how can you understand and apply this rating? IIC is Impact Insulation Class. Predominantly it means how well an underlayment reduces the sound of a footfall, furniture drag, spoon fall, etc.

  • One issue is how the manufacturer is allowed to report the product testing. The testing is always done on new material. There is no requirement to ‘put a bookshelf on it’ and come back in six months and test it then – to see if the material has crushed out. That’s what happens in real life and why the acoustic performance of so much acoustic underlayment degrades so quickly. Which is why the testing requirement, under ANSI standards 118.12 regarding shear strength, is so important.
  • The second thing that should throw up red flags for you is the inclusion of a Sound Transmission Class(STC) rating in the product literature or packaging. Airborne sound only respects mass or separated mass. That thin piece of rubber, foam, cork or felt has nothing to do with increasing or decreasing the STC rating. Higher is better but it’s only relevant if they tell you what the whole assembly is. Different underlayment only influences STC ratings by a miniscule amount; underlayment has almost no mass.
  • It should be noted that unless specifically requested by the flooring manufacturer, vapor barriers are not required for installations on cured concrete above grade

2. Does it meet the IIC requirement of this building?

What is a reasonable requirement for the financial demographics of your building?

  • This is a question that must be answered by the board of directors in conjunction with information the project manager or consultant brings to the table. Different buildings have different financial demographics. Asking a resident who can only afford $0.99 laminate to buy a $3.00 per sq. ft. underlayment is unreasonable. However, in an upscale building the residents and board will expect/demand that the property management company does not allow their building to ‘go bad’ by allowing underperforming underlayment. This class of owner does not want ensuing noise complaints or a reputation that could devalue the property. Here a $ 3.00 underlayment may be a reasonable request.
  • Nearly all reported IIC ratings will be with a wood floor finish of some kind. An 8” concrete slab on its own will typically have an IIC from 32-36. Low-end underlayment can provide a Delta IIC (improvement) of 18-19 points, bringing the assembly to 50-55 IIC. This is the low end of where you would want to be – but it may be all that is feasible for certain buildings. High-end underlayment can provide a Delta IIC of 21-32 points yielding assemblies that range from 53-68. That is all that can be expected on an 8” slab with no drop ceiling. A tile installation will be at least 5-8 points below this. Understanding this allows us to realize that IIC claims going beyond 70 should be regarded with suspicion.

3. What is the product made of?

What will happen as this product ages? Will it harden, crush, dry out, absorb, or wick?

  • It really does make a huge difference in what it’s made of.
  • Underlayment in general is made of, cork, foam, rubber or felt. Below is a breakdown of each underlayment and there performance

CORK

The most popular of underlayment currently. This is the material that has been grandfathered forever, because it’s been around forever. On a 6” concrete slab with a wood floor and 5 mm cork you’ll get approximately a 50 IIC. On an 8” slab it could get up to 55 IIC. Cork is kind of a known commodity but has some downstream issues that should be considered. Cork is, as we know, bark off a tree. Let’s look at a product we all know and love for an example of its performance – wine! Wine corks are top quality because they protect precious cargo. Now, mentally pull the cork out of your favourite two-year-old bottle. The end of the cork that was next to the wine is still soft and pliable. What’s the other end like? It’s compressed, hard, dry and showing signs of getting flaky. That’s because it was exposed to the air. The same happens with the thin layer of cork under flooring. It dries, gets harder and flakes out – along with it goes the acoustic properties we needed to begin with

FOAM

Foam does a reasonable job of taking up any minor irregularities in the subfloor and they do take away some of the ‘clacky’ sound laminate can have as you walk on it. When foam is new and ‘fluffy’ it exhibits some reasonable sound control properties. But there’s a problem. The problem is foam cannot withstand ongoing loads. It eventually crushes out and along with that physical deformation goes the sound control properties that we need. Many foam products available today are re-purposed packaging material; foam gained a foothold on the underlayment market because it’s cheap. But you get what you pay for in the sound control department here. Here’s a really easy test any project manager can do. Take any underlayment and put it under the corner of your desk or a chair leg for a few days. Then take it out, let it recover for a few minutes then look at it and feel it. Did it permanently deform? It will do the same over time under the flooring in that suite

RUBBER

Rubber underlayment is becoming the new Granddaddy on the market. In Europe and North America, it is being made by companies that used to manufacture cork. Rubber exhibits superior sound control properties, strength and aging characteristics that make it particularly suitable for sound control underlayment. Made from strong, recycled tires, rubber cannot be crushed out. This underlayment can be grossly overloaded but recover completely when the load is removed. It is timeless in that they will never have to be replaced in the lifetime of the building. However, rubber does not add any additional strength properties to the flooring assembly.  Also, a major concern with rubber is that it releases harmful toxins over time. Some of these chemicals appear on the Office of Environment Health Hazard Assessment’s (OEHHA) Reference Exposure Lists

FELT

Felt underlayment exhibits good sound control properties and generally good aging characteristics. It does a great job with sound control, but again there are downstream issues that could become a big problem. A wood or laminate floor is actually a collection of pieces with spaces in between that narrow and widen with the seasons as the materials react to the humidity levels. This is natural. While felt exhibits good sound control and support characteristics, it also allows liquid to ‘wick’ laterally under the flooring. Once this happens, the floor fails. What are the chances that a floor will experience a spill in its lifetime? Probably 100 percent. If a felted underlay is used and a spill occurs, resulting in floor failure, who’s responsible?

The Questions to Ask:

Here are the questions you need to come armed with when investigating any acoustic underlayment.

  1. Has the project manager, board of directors, and even an outside third-party consultant set up reasonable, realistic IIC criteria for the building(s) in question?
  2. Does the underlayment literature clearly show the building assembly that it was tested on? If not, request the test data. If it is forthcoming, does it match this building’s construction?
  3. Finally: What is it made of? Will it harden or dry out over time? Will the material crush out over time? Will it wick liquid laterally under the flooring if exposed to a spill?

*Source hushcitysp.com

Laying on Level Wooden Subfloor

Due to their swelling and shrinkage behaviour, wooden planks are a critical installation substrate for rigid coverings made of ceramic plates and natural stones. Old wooden floors often have irregularities, that need to be leveled before laying ceramic or stone tiles. The wooden planks must be screwed to vibration-free, load-bearing wooden beam constructions (max. 40 cm beam spacing). Sufficient rear ventilation must be ensured. In order to lay a ceramic slab or a natural stone covering on wooden planks without damage, it must be decoupled from the substrate. As a positive side effect, this also improves impact sound.

 1 

Wooden Substrate

 2 

Sound Silent 7 decoupling boards

 3 

Mortar

 4 

Floor Covering (tile)

 5 

Grout and sealer

CAD Files

Sound Silent 7: Steel Joist with Wood Subfloor System
Sound Silent 7: 2x10 Wood Joist System

Request a Sample

Request a Meeting

Laying on Concrete

Due to the shrinkage process that takes place during the hydration and drying phase, concrete is subject to a reduction in volume. Therefore, on concretes younger than six months, rigid coverings should not be laid with conventional products. Otherwise, the resulting stresses can result in sustainable composite faults and pavement detachment if occupied too quickly. Depending on the age of the concrete, we recommend different, deformable adhesive mortar systems and/or decoupling, which can safely absorb any changes in shape from the substrate.

 1 

Concrete Substrate

 2 

Optional Primer (Per manufacturer’s guidelines)

 3 

Sound Silent 7 decoupling boards

 4 

Mortar

 5 

Floor Covering (tile)

 6 

Grout and sealer

CAD Files

Sound Silent 7: Concrete on Metal Deck
Sound Silent 7: I-Joist System